Debate on Smoke Free Homes Programme

Last week, Prestonpans Infant School and other East Lothian schools were invited to take part in a new health initiative, The Smoke Free Homes Programme, where children make lealets for their families, asking them to allow them to live in smoke free homes, either by

1. declaring homes completely smoke free and smokers agreeing to smoke outside or

2. smokers agreeing to smoke in a room that children don’t go into.

The reason for the campaign is that children living with smokers are passive smokers themselves because they inhale Second Hand Smoke and that there is conclusive proof that this Second Hand Smoke affects children’s health and leads to these children being more likely to smoke.    The campaign is not a Stop Smoking Campaign but asks adults to pledge not to smoke in the  room/car when children are there.

I circulated the email to staff and to the Parent Council for their consideration and asked them to reply to all.  I’ve since asked if I can publish the responses on the website and so here they are. 

“I am all for things like this in schools, my son was taught about the dangers and effects of drugs,drinking and smoking in primary 4 and at that time I was a smoker myself,but to hear your child speak about the effect of smoking and the dangers to his health really hit home and thanks to the primary school teaching this. I have been a non-smoker for 4 years and please feel free to use this as an example”

“If this was as part of a Health Week, then it could be useful and relevant.  As a stand-alone project it may well go beyond parental ‘involvement’ and into the realm of ‘interference’ – and may be well ineffective.  At the risk of sounding like my 11 year old: What’s the point?  This WHO report from 2006 ( www.euro.who.int/document/e88185.pdf ) casts some doubt on whether Health Promoting Schools are effective in improving health and well-being in the long-term.”

“Like you Sheila, I am also a smoke hater who grew up as a passive smoker and do everything possible to avoid being in someone’s company when they are smoking.
I do however think the school should teach the dangers of smoking, as well as the effects of drink & drugs but must stop short of interfering.   It can be difficult enough to get parents/carers on side with the school and parent council and I could see this being a barrier to some.”
 
“By all means teach kids the rights and wrongs of smoking, alcohol and drugs but it must be treated delicately with a view of children trying to tell their parents not to do it, as it is a strong interference into personal lives and may cause may harm than good.”
 
“This raises a range of ethical and moral dilemmas for us all. I too had experience of a childhood, both graced by loving parents, and blighted by passive smoking.  Let us all remember the perspective of power. We have power, as parents, over the choices with our children. Professional staff have the power with parents, in their professional relationship and role.  So much good can be done by the professional team, ensuring parents are enabled to make informed, beneficial choices for their families. However, respect for private family life (Article 8, ECHR) must be respected before intervention.
A difficult one to balance, but I would argue caution before intervention. If we get too obsessed re the vague Curriculum for Excellence, do children end up attempting to ensure the outcome asked for ?    Yes, smoking is one of the many perils our children face. But many other are faced every day.  From my view, there are better things for the school team to spend time on! “
 
We’d be interested in your thoughts so please comment or give your opinions to school staff or to the Parent Council.  Thank you Parent Council.  I really appreciate the way you are all so willing to think and to engage in debate. 
This entry was posted in Health, Parent Council, Parents and Carers by Sheila Laing. Bookmark the permalink.
Avatar of Sheila Laing

About Sheila Laing

Having lived and worked in West Pilton, Edinburgh for 30 years, I am now really happy to be living in Port Seton and Headteacher of Prestonpans Infant School. What excites me about working in schools is the opportunity to nurture children, families and communities to learn and to celebrate life and learning. Since 2005, I have been inspired by the community of Burmese refugees in Mae Sot, Thailand, who struggle against incredible odds to give the best education possible to their children. I've been honoured to spend time with them each summer and pray the changes in Burma will give freedom to her people.

One thought on “Debate on Smoke Free Homes Programme

  1. Smoking is the single biggest preventable cause of illness, disease and early death in Scotland.
    Passive smoking by children is a major cause of many childhood respiatory problems.
    Children who are exposed to smoking are more likely to take up the habit as teenagers.
    Most adults who smoke say they would like to give up – we should all do whatever we can to prevent children being exposed to tobacco smoke..

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>