Given today’s Scotland Vs England world cup rugby fixture (we’ll not refer to the result) I thought it might be of interest to try to compare headteacher pay between the two countries.
The English pay scales are set out in Pay and Conditions for Teachers in England Wales and I’ll use this document as the basis for what follows.
In this example I will use a secondary school of 900 students, split equally into six year groups of 150 students..
The English system is based upon the concept of pupil units.
For example a student in Key Stage 3 – equivalent to S1 – S2 (12-14 yrs) – is worth 9 units; a student in Key Stage 4 (14-16 yrs) is worth 11 units; and a student in Key Stage 5 (16-18 yrs) is worth 13 units.
Using the 150 students in each year group this translates into 9,900 units.
The units are then compared to a school group table – for the sake of this exercise I’m only going to refer to the scales for schools outwith the London area.
The scales are:
Group Pay range
1 - up to 1000 £42,379 – £56,950
2 – up to 2,200 £44,525 – £61,288
3 – up to 3,500 £48,024 – £65,953
4 – up to 5,000 £51,614 – £70,991
5 – up to 7,500 £56,950 – £78,298
6 – up to 11,000 £61,288 – £86,365
7 – up to 17,000 £65,963 – £95,213
8 – beyond 17,000 £75,725 – £105,097
In our example, the headteacher of a school of 900 students would be paid – at the top end – and most of them seem to be at that level £86,365, whereas in Scotland the pay is a maximum £66,000 for an identical school.
The final level of a headteachers’ pay is determined by the Governing Body (i.e. parents) within the scales set out above – although there is some leeway for awarding additional discretionary payments.
There are addditional scales of pay for headteachers of “special schools” but for the sake of simplicity I’ve ignored them in this comparision.
There does not seem to be a significant difference between the level of pay for basic grade teachers in England and Scotland but there are very significant differences in the pay of headteachers - particularly at secondary level. English headteachers would appear to be paid between 20 – 30% more than their Scottish counterparts.
The key differences in terms of expectation is that the English school governing body can set performance targets that they expect the headteacher to achieve, and the fact that English Headteachers have a greater range of devolved responsibilities than their Scottish counterparts.